#4180 • Autograph of Civil War Navy Officer David Dixon Porter

Part of Fine and Decorative Arts | March 19, 2026 at 10:00 AM (live auction by Alderfer Auction)

High bid $325.00

Status: SOLD

Autograph of David Dixon Porter (1813-1891) United States Navy officer and admiral during the American Civil War. Autographed letter in pencil regarding Ulysses S. Grant's thoughts on General George G. Meade. Letter dated Brighton House, Atlantic City, July 20, 1886 and is addressed to I.R. Pennypacker, Editor of the Wekly Press. Letter reads "Dear Sir, Please excuse my not answering your letter sooner as I have been unable to use a pen. I am always glad to say anything pleasant about General Meade as I have a high regard for him both as a military man and a personal friend. The remark that you heard that General Grant made about his ability as a military man was not quite correct, tho quite as near as these things come when repeated once or twice. One night at City Point just before the surrender of Richmond while talking to General Grant in his tent, I asked him how he estimated General Meade as a Military man. "Why, ( .he answered) I esteem him highly, and second only to Sherman and but for his quick temper he would have no superior." And yet he added "with that quick temper goes his quick perception of what is required on the field of battle, and marks his judgment so unexceptional, he seldom makes mistakes." This was almost verbatim what was said on that occasion. I was with General Grant (then President) when a telegram was brought in announcing his death. He handed to me and said "That is sad news, but what a calamity it would have been had it happened during the war." Grant deeply felt General Meade's death, and his loss to the country-excuse me for using pencil. I remain respectfully yours, David D. Porter". Letter is 3pp with page measuring 10" x 7.75". Provenance: Gibbs family collection, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Members of the Gibbs family, most notably Alvin J Gibbs and James W. Gibbs were discerning and dedicated collectors of autographs, books, and other antiques. The Gibbs family founded the Gibbs Manufacturing Company of Canton, Ohio in 1829 that evolved over the years from farming implement manufacture to notions and toys.

Autograph of Civil War Navy Officer David Dixon Porter